
A food blog in December is probably the wrong place to write about fasting. I don’t feel entirely at ease even using the word; I don’t like the associations fasting has with extreme self-denial and zealous religious observance. Two weeks ago, though, from Tuesday after lunch to about the same time Friday, I ate nothing whatsoever and I drank nothing but boiled water.
This was a unique occurrence. My circumstances are such that I have never been forced to go hungry. My temperament is such that I have never wanted to. My constitution is such that, in the event of an apocalypse, I would – tearfully, and not without remorse – kill, cook and eat the Idiot Boy if I had to. I never lose my appetite. I can eat my way through gloom, illness or bereavement. Three hours after chemotherapy and two hours after simultaneously launching the contents of my stomach and leaking the contents of my bowels all over an ambulance, I could still eat king prawn foo yung and pistachio ice cream. If I’d been Madame Defarge, I’d wouldn’t have been knitting in the guillotine’s front row; I’d have been eating chips.
My main reason for not eating for three days wasn’t to do with weight, exactly, nor, heaven forbid, detoxing. That’s another reason for not liking the f-word, its connotations of the gullibly narcissistic, or pitiably anxious, being conned – by the likes of turd-gazing faux-doctor Gillian McKeith, etc – into thinking their bodies are riddled with festering poisons. Like every other reasonably healthy human being, I have operational lungs, liver, bowels, kidneys and skin. If you are pooping, peeing, sweating or exhaling, you are doing all the de-toxing you will ever need, unless you are bitten by an an anaconda or are the subject of a Russian assassination attempt. Paying someone to stick a hose up your bum to ‘clean’ your colon is more likely to be the first step on the road to a Darwin Award than lead to a beautiful, new you.
The reason I wanted to try something as alarming and depressing as a water fast was that I had read numerous reports of its efficacy for the long term reduction of the pain and inflammation of arthritis, which I have in my knees, feet, hips and, increasingly – aggravatingly – in my hands. Recently the pain in my left hand has resulted in every minor bump or bit of clumsiness being accompanied by a string of profanities. I decided to try going without food for three days before I resigned myself to ratcheting up my painkiller and anti-inflammatory intake for the next couple of months, particularly as the drugs compel me to be pretty much teetotal. So this was definitely not a detox, rather a desperate attempt to ensure I could unhesitatingly over-indulge in all those lovely Christmas boozes.
The other reason I was interested in trying it was weight-related. I know full well that short-term starvation is not the way to lose weight. I wanted to see if it significantly changed my appetite and eating habits afterwards, in the longer term. I need to lose some weight to ease the pressure on my dodgy joints (and fit back in to my favourite frocks). I have been shrinking gradually over the last few months, but I really liked the idea of ‘rebooting’ my appetite, to help me sustain, and hopefully increase, that loss over the next few. My problem is that, not only can I eat in pretty much any circumstance, but I can – and will – always eat more than I need. I often write in my recipes about making double quantities for freezing, but if I seldom mention leftovers, that’s because I almost never have any. This seemed like the ideal time of year to boost my near non-existent ability to portion control, particularly as the festive season started very early for me, with two weekends of lovely house-guests to cook for and some fine restaurant meals in November.
I read up quite a bit on the side-effects and risks, but I didn’t consult my doctor. I am a middle-aged woman of sound body – apart from the arthritis – and fairly sound mind, so I didn’t see the point of wasting the NHS’s time over something any healthy, adult mammal should be able to cope with. I did, however, plan to stay at home for the whole three days, as I knew it could make me feel unpleasantly faint and nauseous. This is what happened:
First 24 hours: I stopped eating at about three in the afternoon, and made sure my last day’s meals were veg and protein heavy to sustain me and keep me feeling full. I decided to start half way through a day, as I know that I am always hungriest and most prone to snack in the afternoon, so I thought if my resolve started to quake at that point a day later, I’d know I’d be just about to unlock the achievement of completing the first 24 hours successfully. This strategy really worked.
On the first morning I didn’t feel particularly hungry; I did desperately want coffee or tea. I am not even sure I was craving caffeine, exactly, it’s just that I usually do measure out my life in coffee spoons. I drink one or two cafetieres of coffee, a couple of pots of green tea and a hot chocolate every day while I am working from home. These soothing hot beverages punctuate and regulate my day; they mark my ‘breaks’. Time seemed to have no meaning without them. Boiled water was a very poor substitute, indeed. At one point I found myself opening and closing my mouth like a sort of demented baby bird, longing for my hot silky, caffeine worm. I missed drink much more than food.
The evening wasn’t too bad. I kept my distance while the Idiot Boy ate his dinner, but managed to watch Masterchef without licking the screen. I did feel mildly irritable, but I often do.
Second 24 hours: I dozed through much of this day, and even when I wasn’t asleep, I was mostly horizontal. By the afternoon I found it quite hard to concentrate on my book, and kept zoning out of the radio programme I was trying to listen to. I did attempt to do a couple of domestic chores, but found them too much effort. I read Facebook and my emails, and posted a recipe (which was mostly pre-written) on here, but these activities took longer than they normally would. I wouldn’t say I felt faint, exactly; it was more like being slightly stoned. I also began to feel a bit stir crazy, but would not have felt comfortable or safe leaving the house.
I was mostly unaffected by the Idiot Boy cooking bacon and eating his dinner, though the smells seemed almost sickeningly strong, rather than appetising. Masterchef seemed like a broadcast from an alien planet (even more so than usual, I mean) and the food on display looked unnaturally bright, as though it were made with Lego or Plasticine. I was, however, aware that I was psychologically hungry. My belly was empty and rumbling a bit, but I wasn’t starving. I just ached for the comfort and routine of cooking and eating. Like the coffee, these domestic rituals punctuate and progress my day. Without eating or going out my days were completely shapeless.
Physically I felt quite odd. My joints, by the 48 hour mark, were much less painful and more flexible than they usually are, especially the left index finger which had really causing me pain lately, but the enforced inactivity was making me feel stiff (like most arthritic people, I generally have more difficulty and discomfort with sustained immobility; my mobility isn’t yet particularly impaired). The flexibility was markedly better than it is when I take anti-inflammatories, and exceeded my expectations. I was fed up and bored and dopey by the end of 48 hours – the hardest point – but the difference in my joints was enough to make me keep going.
Third 24 hours I felt weak, drowsy and miserably bored by this stage. I did virtually nothing. I couldn’t really sustain an interest in reading or Facebook, and found it very hard to concentrate on the film I was watching – Donnie Darko, which probably was a bit too trippy for my enfeebled state, really – though I also found it much more emotional than I would normally. It was only towards the second half of this day that I felt I physically needed food, rather than merely wanting it. I felt quite literally drained. I’d obviously emptied put my digestive system and was pooping like a new born baby; presumably living off your own lard is similar to living off breast milk.
When I had read up about people doing water only fasts under medical supervision in expensive hospitals and health farms, I’d read that they were instructed not to shower, bathe or use lotions, deodorants or toothpaste. I ignored these instructions, because the showering and bathing ban was due to the risk that people might faint in the shower and hurt themselves, and the lotions ban was apparently because of the increased sensitivity to smell. I definitely had the latter, but bathing and moisturising were the absolute highlight of my day. I fell asleep in every bath – I sometimes do on ordinary days – but I am pretty sure I’d have woken up if I’d inhaled any water and if I hadn’t, well, more fool me, really. The toothpaste ban was to avoid the stomach being tricked into thinking food was in your mouth, and secreting acid expectantly. I slooshed with mouthwash, and that seemed okay, but by day three my mouth felt slimy and horrible, so I did brush my teeth with toothpaste. This was a bad mistake; my mouth filled with saliva, my stomach reacted noisily, and it was the only time I felt really sick. I drank a glass of cold water, quickly, but still felt pretty rotten for some time afterwards, and only held out because I wanted to achieve the 72 hour mark.
Results: I broke my fast with a home made soya protein shake with blueberries and cocoa. These shakes are what I used to snack on after strenuous exercise when I was much more active, and what I sometimes have in lieu of lunch if I know I am going out for dinner, so I can maximise my appetite and capacity for fine food later (I am never a cheap date). The quite bland shake seemed as rich as a creamy chocolate mousse. I couldn’t actually drink it from the glass, as it was too rich and ‘physical’ somehow, poking my nose into the cup and have stuff going into my mouth. I had to eat with a spoon, very slowly, in three installments. About ten minutes after the first installment, I felt fantastic. I felt jubilant, powerful, amazing. It can’t have been a sugar rush – not from a handful of blueberries – but it was a very intense feeling of well-being restored. That night I ate a small portion of salmon and spinach, again in installments, and felt very, very full. The next day, a mouthful of cheese – my snacking nemesis – felt like the richest, creamiest, most delightful thing ever. Possibly because it is, of course, but I felt I was making this wonderful discovery for the first time.
I was pleased enough with the effect on my joints to fast like this again. If doing so occasionally eases my discomfort and reduces my need for painkillers, it’s definitely worth the temporary dreariness. I am not sure I could fast for longer than 72 hours even though six days is supposedly the optimal time (though I suspect a hospital taking wads of dollars off you per day to let you sit in a room and drink filtered water would say that). It definitely worked as a way of rebooting my appetite and making it easier to eat less, and less frequently. My sweet tooth has been diminishing for a while, as it does with most people as they age, but fasting seems to have accelerated the process. I haven’t even fancied a mince pie, one of my favourite seasonal foods, since. I still snack on cheese, but less frequently and in much smaller portions. I’m eating more mindfully and appreciatively.
It has now been exactly two weeks since I started the fast. I lost about nine pounds over the three days (my scales aren’t accurate). Afterwards ,I found it easy to take up the small-portion, low GI way of eating that usually works for me if I want to lose (or not gain) weight. I am eating less food, more slowly and more carefully. I am drinking less coffee than I used to. This is not deliberate, as I don’t have any qualms about caffeine, I just don’t want it as much. The first post-fast coffee I had tasted extraordinarily bitter, the way I first remember it tasting when I was a child. I have kept off the nine pounds and lost a little more. The only time I have eaten more than I feel I should have, was the only time I had had some booze, at a meal with some girlfriends. As ever, booze is the gateway drug to more food (and more booze). Who ever went into a cheap kebab shop sober? I have no intention of giving up drinking, I am just saving it for high days and holidays.
Generally, I feel better for the experience. It has lessened my joint pain and my appetite, and given me a bit of a rest and energy boost. I would not do it again if I was feeling depressed, as the enforced isolation and inactivity and general dreariness would, I am sure, make me feel worse. I wouldn’t do it if I lived alone for similar reasons, and because seeing someone everyday who was encouraging and distracting and who administered fuss and back rubs made it much less onerous. It think it would be impossible to combine with caring for a child or doing normal work outside the home or having to cook for someone else.
The most remarkable aspect of it, for me, was being so clearly aware of the difference between real, physical hunger and conditioned, psychological hunger, because I was constantly forced to question whether or not I really was properly hungry. Now I seem to be enjoying less food, more.